The Perfect Insider: Episodes 8 & 9

perins89_2 “Purple Dawn”/”Yellow Blind Spot”

Thursdays at 2:00 pm EST on Crunchyroll

Moe attempts to find out who talked to her in the virtual reality while Saikawa struggles to commit to his promise of keeping Shiki’s death a secret. When the police arrives, however, all the puzzle pieces start falling into place.

Aqua’s thoughts

Well, I know this is supposed to be a double feature, but damn, everything I wanted to say about episode 8 is pretty much invalidated by that tidal wave of twists at the end of episode 9. I figured the murder would be something of Shiki’s own creation, but I always suspected it was the robot, and not — well — an actual child. The revelation that Shiki was pregnant when she went into exile is nonetheless a brilliant twist that perfectly fits the show’s general theme of killing your parents and breaking free from their shackles. Looks like Shiki’s daughter inherited her mother’s desire to ascend humanity and become a ‘perfect insider’, an isolated genius not bogged down by any familial ties or obligations, and ironically, Shiki got in the way of the ambitions that led her to kill her parents herself in some sort of twisted coming-of-age ritual.

If the Shiki Moe talked to inside the virtual reality machine actually was the murderer, then Shiki 2 (SHIKI?) may have tried to go even further in her desires to become ‘free’ by uploading herself onto a computer. It’s a bizarre chain of libertine violence, of geniuses killing each other in increasingly more scheming ways, and both Moe and Saikawa seem to have a stake in solving it because they are afraid it might drag them along as well. Both Shiki and Shiki jr. (never to be confused with ridiculously catchy j-pop band Shiggy jr.) have been taunting Moe with the mysterious deaths of her parents for the entire show now, and Saikawa is so obsessed with Shiki’s ‘perfect insider’ ideology that she might just be the only thing keeping him from going the extra mile. Episode 8 spends a lot of time fleshing out their relationship, and it clearly shows that their dynamic has evolved past a grating pseudo-romance.


Yet being so obsessed with Shiki’s libertarian ideology, it’s quite the surprise that Saikawa would willingly go along in Yamane’s scam. The whole thing turned out to not really go anywhere at all, which does make me wonder if it served only to imply that Yamane is worryingly concerned about the state of the lab. Did he kill the director over some sort of petty squabble regarding the mysterious thing they’re working on? Saikawa himself finally brings up the possibility of a second killer in Episode 8, though he once again claims that the killer, after killing Shiki, lied in wait for the director and killed him as well. Admittedly, Shiki jr. has a perfect motif, given that the director is likely her father, but we still have 2 episodes left, and Yamane has been acting suspiciously enough for there to be yet another twist. If it’s not him, it might be one of the other dozens of characters who’ve shown up in this show for no good reason (Miki?).

Whatever The Perfect Insider still has in stock, It’d be rather disappointing of the following two episodes simply consist of Saikawa explaining how he figured out the case. Moe has been our de facto main character for a while now, and the idea that the frankly boring, insufferable Professor figured the entire case out while she was off going through, like, character development just doesn’t sit well with me. It’s not that I think the big reveal is rushed or anything — The Perfect Insider has always been more about figuring out the killer’s motive, rather than their methods — but for Saikawa to casually announce the truth after several episodes of dicking around behind the scenes just feels as if Moe, and by extension, the audience she represents, is being robbed of the knowledge she is entitled to.


All in all, The Perfect Insider has somehow managed to turn itself from an endearing character study into a bona fide murder twistery. So yeah, here’s hoping they aren’t letting us of the hook just yet.

Random observations

  • I’m certain Moe’s bizarre getup consisting of a tiger-stripe bikini, a towel cape and bland name baby blue Chuck Taylors will win her several Best Dressed Anime Character of 2015 awards.
  • Shimada’s room contains a bunch of posters referencing a whole load of obscure noitaminA deep cuts. Remember Fractale? No. 6? [C]: The Money of Soul and Possibility Control? Is it me or does Shimada have terrible taste in anime?
  • As brilliant as the clock twist actually is, wouldn’t a normal computer, if ever made to automatically produce a file with the same name as a file that already exists, simply rename the second file as ‘(1)’?
  • Never thought we’d see Chupacabra Girl again, but, err, does she actually have a reason for being in this show?
  • ‘I will not let you do this’ is a bit of a sloppy translation for Shiki’s dad’s last words. You can’t exactly ‘let’ someone be pregnant. How about ‘I will not allow this’?

9 thoughts on “The Perfect Insider: Episodes 8 & 9

  1. I was mildly amused when Yamane said he would replace the whole OS with Unix. Seems awfully illogical to leave the programming of a prison facility to the prisoner,though the aftermath is logical.

    From the evidence gathered though, I would wager the actual victim was Shiki’s daughter. Going by detective logic in fictional works like this, the fact that she has not aged much at all apparently, seems to be a clue that somewhere along the way, Shiki may have substituted herself with her daughter in the video feeds.

    That the F stands for fifteen could also mean the age of the child when she was ready for the plan to be implemented.

    My hypothesis however, still lacks motive as it does not explain why Shiki would try to escape.

    • I knew something about the whole Unix thing was fishy, but I know pretty much nothing about IT so that whole bit just sort of happened for me. Your hypothesis is interesting, but yeah, I don’t see why Shiki would do that. Maybe because her daughter was also preventing her from being ‘free’? I think Shiki’s daughter killing her mother makes more sense looking at the bigger picture, though.

      • I kinda got the vibe that Shiki killed her daughter too, but you are right that it would be more thematically coherent for it to be the other way around. She does claim to have multiple personalities, what if one of them is her now deceased daughter?

        It being her daughter who died would also work into why they thought Shiki’s sister could double as her, what if she actually does look like her, and the only one Moe ever met was her daughter?

        • Great thread. I think there is a pretty large gap nobody has addressed (or perhaps I missed it). Wouldn’t having another stomach to feed dramatically increase the food delivered to Shiki? Also wouldnt the child need formula, diapers, vaccinations, etc, etc, etc. Clearly the Legos were for the kid,,,,but what about everything else a human being needs to survive?

          • I think we can classify that as willing suspension of disbelief. The guard did mention at some point that she made all sorts of weird requests that they delivered to her without question. Also, I guess you don’t technically need all those things (except for food) to raise a child. Maybe her entire point was to raise a feral child, create a human reduced to their primal state oh god i am thinking this through waaaay too much

  2. What a twist! I never imagined a 13 year old girl would be pregnant in the show, but that’s what makes it even more shocking. yes you are correct the computer will automaticall create a file name with (1) so it does not overwrite the original. It’s possible Shiki’s Redo Majikku OS circumvented that. What’s the whole point of having a child you know will murder you as you did your own parents?

    Regarding Yamane, I find it odd he non-chalantly was OK with our dynamic duo not keeping the murders a secret after practically begging them to keep it under wraps…What does he have up his sleeve?

    Moe’s getup at the end was extremely cute.

    • I think Shiki knew her own daughter would kill her because I assume that is simply how she thinks people should act. In order to become perfectly free, she had to kill her own parents, and she wants her daughter to break free from her in the same way.

      • Does that mean Shiki wanted to die thus destroying her “Perfect insider” status for the sake of procreation? It just doesn’t jive with what we know about her. Why go through all this trouble to set yourself free only to be brutally murdered yourself?

        Either way I always look forwrad to the show and it has me constantly trying to refresh my memory trying to figure shit out.

        • I assume that she thinks that this is just the way the world has to work. She found out she was pregnant, locked herself up so she could raise her child as a ‘perfect insider’, which would culminate in her daughter killing her to cut herself free from the last person they have any sort of tie with. Maybe it was all part of a plan to create the ‘perfect insider’?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.