First Look: Holmes of Kyoto

Alternative title(s): Holmes at Kyoto Teramachi Sanjo, Kyoto Teramachi Sanjo no Holmes
Novel Adaptation by Seven
Streaming on Crunchyroll

Premise

At a high-end antique shop in Kyoto’s Teramachi Sanjou shopping district, a young man named Yagashira Kiyotaka (aka Holmes) works as the main shopkeeper for his father and grandfather. When high school student Mashiro Aoi comes in one day hoping to get a family antique appraised and sold, she ends up working there part-time. Together, they solve odd cases brought to them by their clients.

Artemis’ verdict: Tedious

While I can’t think of anything truly terrible to say about Holmes, I also really can’t think of any reason to praise it, or any reason to keep watching at all for that matter. For the most part I found myself profoundly bored, from Aoi reminiscing about an event that happened two weeks ago at the beginning of the episode (although the way she spoke about it, I expected it to be months or years) to Holmes’ stupid assertion that he’s a ‘nasty Kyoto boy’ at the end. Honestly, I’m getting pretty tired of mystery or detective-themed anime referring to the name Holmes for no good reason. While I get the pun behind the name here (and can at least appreciate the fact that the character isn’t the one who gave it to himself), the fact that it’s included at all in the show strikes me as fairly pointless, even detrimental, to the series as a whole. Invoke a name like Holmes and you’re going to get comparisons, deserved or not –and most of them will likely not be flattering.

It doesn’t help that Holmes looks incredibly cheap. Even if you happen to like the somewhat generic character designs and overly filtered colour palette, the background art in particular appears very slapdash. Faces from afar are often shown sans any detail whatsoever (eyes, nose, mouth, the lot, even of the two main characters), any antiques that aren’t being shoved directly in front of the camera are clearly drawn in the space of about second with near-identical outlines, and the few visual details of any person or object that are included just aren’t particularly pretty or well-animated.

My advice is to skip over this one unless you need some help getting to sleep. It’s largely inoffensive, sure, but it’s also dull as ditchwater.

Jel’s verdict: Antiques Roadshow: The Anime

My verdict might be a little misleading since I actually enjoy Antiques Roadshow and the antique talk was arguably the most interesting part of the episode. It’s everything else that is extremely boring, particularly the characters. The show wants us to believe our main guy is some “nasty” bad boy and our main girl is hot tempered enough to sell a national treasure just to yell at her ex-boyfriend. In practice though, they’re both super polite and just stand around talking. In this rough season I can at least appreciate there’s nothing offensively bad here, but there’s also not much reason to keep watching.

2 thoughts on “First Look: Holmes of Kyoto

  1. Ditchwater gets a bad rap. I was also very disappointed in this and surprised to see other bloggers enjoying it. I was about to give it another chance. Good thing i found this post

    • I won’t say there’s zero redeeming features about the show, but presumably others bloggers are seeing something that I simply can’t, because I honestly found nothing enjoyable about this one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.